I am the Seer, I saw the Tanner and the Villager as unused at the time of my vision. I cannot say for anything that happened after I looked.
Avurekhos says, "Dylara's a PvP menace in my eyes, totes rekting face."
The eye of Dylara materialises in your hands and flings itself around your neck, tightening incomprehensibly until it is irremovable. Perfectly clean, this eyeball has been wrenched from the socket of Dylara. It has been animated by some unusual force, constantly looking around itself as if in shock or fear. It is bathed in a light covering of white flames that roll endlessly over its surface. A single chain of empyreal metal pierces either side of the eye, allowing it to be worn around the neck.
Cyndarin: Villager Falmiis: claimed Villager, then claimed Robber (counterclaimed by Tarkenton), claiming to steal Vanilla role from Cyndarin (Minion?) Lavinya: claimed Drunk, unknown now Dylara: claimed Seer (disputed by Tarkenton who accuses Tanner), claim Vanilla and Tanner unused Thul: claimed Troublemaker, first claim switched Tarkenton and Cyndarin, then claim switched Falmiis and Ellowyn Tarkenton: claimed Robber (counterclaimed by Falmiis), then claimed Werewolf to accuse Cyndarin, then, after Thul reveal, reverted to Robber stealing from Dylara, claiming to be Tanner Melali: claimed Hunter (counterclaimed by Tremula) Tremula: claimed Hunter (counterclaimed by Melali)
Luce: claim Mason, claim other Mason is unused
Ellowyn: claim Villager
So, if Dylara is lying that means that the Seer, one Mason, and another unknown role are unused. If she is telling the truth, then the unused roles are Villager, Tanner, and Mason.
Tremula and Melali are both claiming Hunter. One is lying, and the other is a hunter. If each is voting for the other one, we either get the lynch the first time, or we hit the hunter and the hunter shoots the liar.
So, the people whose roles are contested are Falmiis, Dylara, Tarkenton, myself, Tremula, and Ellowyn.
Cyndarin, Lavinya, Thul and Luce seem to make pretty trustworthy claims.
Cyndarin claimed Vanilla Villager since the beginning, before the game actually began. (If this happens in future games, I suggest reshuffling roles.)
Lavinya claimed to be Drunk, and nobody countered her. Since declaring oneself to be Drunk is similar to having a 4/12, or 1/3 chance of being not Town, I don't think Werewolves/Minion would claim it before knowing what the unused roles were. Tanner might, but there are lots of better alternatives to Tanner, and since the other unused roles seem to be Town, we just have to not vote for her.
Thul lied about whom he switched at first, but that method has been proven to be effective in sussing out who is who, from last game. It might not work anymore, if people don't believe the Troublemaker, but it is a decent tactic. Also, nobody else claimed to be Troublemaker, and if the Troublemaker is unused, then Dylara is also lying, and maybe Luce.
Luce waited a long time to claim, but his role is believable, especially since no one else claimed to be Mason. Since no one else claimed to be Mason, that means that both Masons are in the middle. Which would also require Dylara to lie.
If Dylara is lying about being the Seer, then Thul and Luce become less trustworthy, since their roles are only certain if no one else counterclaimed and they are not in the middle.
Aren't the votes done via PM, privately? This isn't Mafia.
And anyway, I know that Tremula is lying, but what if she is only the Minion? After all, coming out indignant and loud is not something a Werewolf would usually do. While we still have a few minutes left, we should fully explore our options before deciding on a course of action.
Well, Tarkenton's playing Robber switched to... he's implying Tanner. If what he's claimed is true, Dylara was lying and still is, Falmiis is lying about ever being a Robber and still is after an Ellowyn switch... Tark's BSing almost for sure.
I'm reasonably sure we can catch something from the hunter play, but if you all want to call Tarkenton's bluff, we can go for it.
I am 100% certain Tark is the Minion. He's too pushy, if it weren't for the fact I saw tanner as unused I'd think he was actually the tanner. But tanner was unused and there was no way he could have stolen it from Lavinya due to order of night tasks.
Avurekhos says, "Dylara's a PvP menace in my eyes, totes rekting face."
The eye of Dylara materialises in your hands and flings itself around your neck, tightening incomprehensibly until it is irremovable. Perfectly clean, this eyeball has been wrenched from the socket of Dylara. It has been animated by some unusual force, constantly looking around itself as if in shock or fear. It is bathed in a light covering of white flames that roll endlessly over its surface. A single chain of empyreal metal pierces either side of the eye, allowing it to be worn around the neck.
A sense of divine wrath or amusement fills the hall as the sun sinks below the horizon. You find yourselves unable to speak another word, and resort to silent prayers naming the one who must die tonight.
Send in those votes via PM!
As the sun sinks below the horizon and the quiet murmur of prayers fades away, three villagers find themselves filled with conviction. Drawing their daggers, Luce, Lavinya, and Ellowyn approach Tremula with daggers drawn, the look in their eyes somewhere between hope and fear. Tremula stands aloof, seemingly unconcerned as she ruminates on a piece of venison jerky. In one fluid motion, Tremula unslings her gun and, just as she swore the previous day, fires a silver bullet right between Melali's pretty little. Astonished gasps fill the hall as Melali collapses to the floor, his body convulsing grotesquely as his very bones and muscles seem to shift. Instantly you see that this so-called villager was no human at all, but a Werewolf!
Tarkenton blanches at the sight and dashes for the door, followed soon after by Falmiis, who appears as surprised as anyone by the set of bristly whiskers now growing from his newly acquired muzzle. But their days are numbered.
Village wins by way of Hunter!
Night roles
1. Melali - Werewolf
2. Luce - Mason
3. Tarkenton - Minion
4. Cyndarin - Villager
5. Thul - Troublemaker
6. Ellowyn - Werewolf
7. Lavinya - Drunk
8. Tremula - Hunter
9. Dylara - Seer
10. Falmiis - Robber
U1 Tanner
U2 Mason
U3 Villager
Night actions:
Wolves Melali and Ellowyn recognize each other
Minion Tarkenton recognizes wolves
Mason Luce sees he is alone
Seer Dylara notes that Tanner (U1) and Villager (U3) are not in use
Robber Falmiis steals Cyndarin's role and becomes a vanilla villager
Troublemaker Thul switches Falmiis's vanilla Villager with Ellowyn's Wolf
Also, for the votes, what happens if there's a tie?
And what effect did my last minute charts have on people?
For a minute it looked like a possible three or four way tie, in which case everyone tied for the most votes would die! If Trem, Tark, Luce, and let's say Cyndarin had all gotten two votes, they would have all been lynched, and Tremula would still have shot Melali. That's still a town victory, but the dead innocents should feel bad.
Nobody let me play lead investigator again. I am bad at it.
Curious why Ellowyn didn't dish dirt on Falmiis. Guess she thought I was going to pull a triple cross? Which would've been hilarious, but no.
Also, feel the need to share this bit of poetry:
----
ONUW Round 3
Being the son of a priest sucks. You spend all day learning rituals and incantations, and all night studying or reciting the prophecies and blessings of Almighty Dog. None of it really even makes sense, but you go through the motions to keep the parents happy. Right now, you're chapters deep in the most incomprehensible tome of Werewolf lore you've ever read - and you've read enough to know it's probably bullshit. As if in answer to your wavering faith, a wild howl breaks the night, followed by a terrified shriek. You feel a strange twinge of fear and exhilaration. Wasn't there something in the prophecies about this night? Is there something to this after all? You call out to your mom and dad but receive no answer, then check the family altar in the basement. No sign of them. Your front door creaks on its hinges and you realize it's been left open. Outside, the village streets are chaos, and the screams of your neighbors echo through the air. Again you feel a rush of excitement, and a little less fear this time. Could it be that your prayers have been answered? Will you finally have.. some free time!? Tentatively, you creep out of your home and slink along the shadows, your studies already forgotten in favor of a new objective: to have some Dog-damned fun for once in your life!
You are the Troublemaker! Drawing on what little you remember from the incantations, you can exchange the identities of two others. Recite the names of those you'd like to swap to Almighty Dog, and He will make your will manifest. Your choices are: Melali, Luce, Tarkenton, Cyndarin, Ellowyn, Lavinya, Tremula, Dylara, and Falmiis. You can also choose not to use these powers. You win when at least one Werewolf is lynched by dusk.
Yep, and the Robber can choose not to take another role. In the case of the TM, swapping and not swapping are roughly equivalent. You can get the same kind of information by bluffing, whether you've swapped or not. But the Robber gets some useful information by stealing and looking at the new role, so I don't think I'd ever advise him not to steal.
Comments
Dylara, you have anything to say really quickly?
The eye of Dylara materialises in your hands and flings itself around your neck, tightening incomprehensibly until it is irremovable.
Perfectly clean, this eyeball has been wrenched from the socket of Dylara. It has been animated by some unusual force, constantly looking around itself as if in shock or fear. It is bathed in a light covering of white flames that roll endlessly over its surface. A single chain of empyreal metal pierces either side of the eye, allowing it to be worn around the neck.
Cyndarin: Villager
Falmiis: claimed Villager, then claimed Robber (counterclaimed by Tarkenton), claiming to steal Vanilla role from Cyndarin (Minion?)
Lavinya: claimed Drunk, unknown now
Dylara: claimed Seer (disputed by Tarkenton who accuses Tanner), claim Vanilla and Tanner unused
Thul: claimed Troublemaker, first claim switched Tarkenton and Cyndarin, then claim switched Falmiis and Ellowyn
Tarkenton: claimed Robber (counterclaimed by Falmiis), then claimed Werewolf to accuse Cyndarin, then, after Thul reveal, reverted to Robber stealing from Dylara, claiming to be Tanner
Melali: claimed Hunter (counterclaimed by Tremula)
Tremula: claimed Hunter (counterclaimed by Melali)
So, if Dylara is lying that means that the Seer, one Mason, and another unknown role are unused. If she is telling the truth, then the unused roles are Villager, Tanner, and Mason.
Total Roles: x2 Werewolves, x2 Mason, Minion, Seer, Robber, Troublemaker, Drunk, x2 Villager, Hunter, Tanner
Tremula and Melali are both claiming Hunter. One is lying, and the other is a hunter. If each is voting for the other one, we either get the lynch the first time, or we hit the hunter and the hunter shoots the liar.
Voting for Tremula.
I'm reasonably sure we can catch something from the hunter play, but if you all want to call Tarkenton's bluff, we can go for it.
The eye of Dylara materialises in your hands and flings itself around your neck, tightening incomprehensibly until it is irremovable.
Perfectly clean, this eyeball has been wrenched from the socket of Dylara. It has been animated by some unusual force, constantly looking around itself as if in shock or fear. It is bathed in a light covering of white flames that roll endlessly over its surface. A single chain of empyreal metal pierces either side of the eye, allowing it to be worn around the neck.
If Tarkenton is telling the truth, then Dylara and Falmiis are both lying. Thus, the roles would look like this:
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."
For a minute it looked like a possible three or four way tie, in which case everyone tied for the most votes would die! If Trem, Tark, Luce, and let's say Cyndarin had all gotten two votes, they would have all been lynched, and Tremula would still have shot Melali. That's still a town victory, but the dead innocents should feel bad.
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."
Estarra the Eternal says, "Give Shevat the floor please."