Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 4.8K All Categories
- 4.3K Life in Lusternia
- 463 Announce Posts
- 75 Event Posts
- 1.7K Common Grounds
- 589 Q&A
- 83 Combat Overhaul
- 1.5K World Library
- 86 Combat Logs
- 870 Event Scrolls
- 403 Mechanic's Corner
- 329 Ideas
- 314 Last Chance Trading Post
- 478 Life Outside of Lusternia
- 9 Forum News
- 275 The Real World
- 94 Meet and Greet
- 37 The Funnies
- 63 Mafia Hideout
New Reporting System
New Reporting System
This new system is intended to allow every player a voice and encourage more discussion amongst the player base to come to an agreement on achieving a more enjoyable game experience.
Any player will be able to put up a report once a month. The report can be about anything whether it is PvP, PvE, QoL, Economy, Library, Family system, whatever.
The system works in two stages. The first stage is primarily for discussion and development. This report will look like our current envoy reports do now, with a problem statement and up to 3 solutions. At this point, there will be two voting options per solution - Support, and Support with Changes, and in order to comment on this report, you must vote first. Once you've voted, you can then comment and even suggest changes. Once this reaches a threshold (yet to be determined, but it'll be low), it'll advance to stage two. If it doesn't reach the threshold within 30 days, it'll be deleted.
Stage two will start with giving the original author a chance to edit it, add more information, adjust the solutions and include solutions suggested in Stage 1. Once that's done, the report will be back up for all players to vote on the solutions and comment. The voting for this stage will consist 'Approve', 'Approve with changes', 'Abstain', and 'Reject.' You'll need to vote in order to comment. At this point, comments made can be turned into solutions by the author, and players will be able to vote on that solution as well. Once this second stage reaches a second, higher threshold, you'll be guaranteed an admin response within 30 days. If it doesn't reach this threshold within a fresh 30 days, it'll be deleted.
As this is a strictly OOC medium, player involvement will not be through their characters, but through their registration. Votes and comments will be anonymous to the rest of the player base. This is to allow people to focus on the issue and the arguments rather than who is making them. Comments will likely be limited to 1/day/report, so players should take their time to really express their points. You can change your vote at anytime, with your last vote being the one that counts.
In regards to the thresholds - votes and comments on any report will count towards the threshold. The first stage threshold is lower and exists in hopes that it encourages players to reach out and discuss issues and come to some common ground for the betterment of the game.
The admin have the final say and a response doesn't mean it will be implemented. There are further considerations to be made beyond player votes, such as what the required effort and time to implement would be and we have to keep that in mind. It's quite possible that we love what's being proposed but just don't have the time to implement it.
Players found to be abusing this new system will have their ability to put up reports, vote or comment removed if we deem it necessary.
We will have a help file that can help guide what we think makes a good report and what kind of information to include.
We know this system isn't perfect, there are a few downsides that could crop up. We're willing to work through those and improve upon or change this system at any given time to make it better.
Let us know your thoughts and concerns below.
9
(c) Iron Realms Entertainment 2012.
Comments
1. Is a person's skill level and/or experience with a skillset, or even whether they have the skill or not, going to add any weight to their vote or credence to their report?
2. Envoy reports often received "Solution 4's" which may or may not have kept with the report's intent. I realise that you aren't able to see the future, but do you forsee this happening often? Or do you feel like the admin overseeing this may try to stick to a "yes or no" judgement on reports.
3. Just to make sure we understand, only one character per registration is able to submit a report?
2) We'll have to see. I think it goes back to the 'other considerations' that may not necessarily be known to the players. What I will say is that I'll do my best to explain why we're going with a solution 4 at the very least.
3) Correct.
1. Will we be able to vote on as many reports as we like, as often as we like - so the vote is solely on the merits of each individual report? Or are we helping to prioritise the most desired changes - so voting is going to be more about which changes we personally benefit from the most/want to see first?
2. Does a 'reject' vote count negatively towards either threshold? So a player rejecting a proposal cancels out the vote of another player approving the proposal?
3. Is there any weighting on votes - will some players count for more (if they are more active, if they have more reports that they have previously had approved, if they have higher combat rankings, etc)?
Not sure if this is decided yet, of course. Just curious!
2) No, every vote will count towards the threshold. This was discussed and it was decided that the most impartial way to go about it was to have every action count towards the threshold.
3) The only consideration we really thought of was to have a minimum play time in order to vote. A major part of the goal here is more inclusion, so we think it's best to make votes equal here.
@Tambador - that is one of the concerns, but again, we're hoping to encourage more cross-org communication to help achieve more engaging gameplay all around.
It's per registration, there is an email associated with each registration, but that won't be public knowledge or really play any part. All it means is you can't put up a report, then jump onto alts to vote for it.