Ushaara · Schrödinger's Traitor
Reactions
Comments
-
Situation as it stands to me is:
1) Silvanus investigated Cyndarin with the result being Cyndarin is mafia.
2) Ellowyn claimed she swapped Cyndarin and Krackenor, so Silvanus' result is actually for Krackenor.
3) Then me claimi… -
After my first night watch attempt of Ssaliss failing, once Ieptix confirmed I was only a watcher, I've just been assuming Ssaliss has been jailing himself away every night. You're right in that he's been very low-key though.
Again … -
I followed Melali's outline and watched Silvanus. No one else targeted him.
My ideal plan of action for today would be lynch Ellowyn and find out for sure if there's a bus driver. If she's town, Silv can use his vigilante dragon head on K… -
Oh, derp, just seeing that Falmiis blocked Cen. Guess that was my fault for throwing suspicion his way last day phase for the convenience of picking the aeoned targets each night.
in Welcome to Night Vale - Mafia Comment by Ushaara June 2016
-
Very quick check-in before bed, but I still see nothing to suggest my resurrection was anything but that so why you're still pushing for Krackenor I don't understand it.
So I am still 100% maintaining that Krackenor should be in the clear… -
Less relevant Sentinels represent! B-)
-
(Quote) Did have Sylandra as option 1, but you're right about yourself, so for completeness
Option 8) Silvanus as hatchet party, since he was blocked by Kiradawea.
-
And one point for @Melali that may change up your plan of action.
When I made the point of saying to think who would have benefited the most from a… -
Options for the missing hatchet party?
1) Falmiis may be on to something since we know for sure Sylandra was blocked.
2) They picked Cyna and failed. I'd assume Cyna would have received a message if this was the case though.Okay, that's the realistic alternative I was thinking it could be. Sylandra's list just seemed like she had no information on you though which doubled up my confusion as to whether that was the case she was also implying.
So now, where di…I know I said I'd shut up, but I can't reconcile where the hatchet killer party fits in to Night 2 if it was a townie who vigged Ayisdra. And looking back at Sylandra's list I'm now uncertain on whether we're thinking of the same alternative scenari…So, yeah, I'm going to shut up since I've probably done more harm than good and confused things. Quite possible I added two and two and got nine. Ieptix, you're an evil overlord and trying to figure out your setup is making my head spin!
Oh.... Think I know who you mean. Hmmmmm!I'm very curious as to who your alternate killer of Ayisdra is because I freely admit pegging those three as mafia starts entirely with Silvanus doing the killing. If that's not the case my theory falls apart!Blargle, I hate the no edit rule. Typos galore.
At this point, I'm still good with the lynch on Kiradawea. I can't really say more to convince you of my Silvanus/Kiradawea/Cen theory, other that to say go back and try consider their actions with the assumption they are a coordinated group.
…If I'm correct with the above theory, I trust that I shall have all your votes in the next election?
After running through some potential scenarios and what they imply, and being fairly confident about what Ssaliss' power will turn out to be and why my attempt at watching failed while revealing he has a night action... at the risk of completely thr…Well whatever the result of whether I'm a true motion detector or not, I am definitely a watcher and half of what I said regarding Falmiis will remain true, he wasn't targeted by anyone last night. Will get back to you if/when Ieptix clarifies what …I will concede the point that I may not be a true motion detector, as that is an interpretation drawn from the fact that I know Ssaliss has a night action, which would not normally be revealed to a pure watcher only.
Also, it is based on…I mean really, if we try work through your scenario which is that I didn't really watch Falmiis last night then, what? Only logical conclusion is it means you think I'm anti-town.
Since there was only a mafia death last night, that would…(Quote) Again, I can only work with the info Ieptix gives me, which from my point of view is 100% consistent with what Falmiis has said himself.
On the other hand, you/mafia are the only person to benefit from trying to cast…(Quote) I'm not ignoring Krackenor having two powers, I'm the only person to have directly witnessed both of them. And from that I am led to believe he is pro-town.
I mean, the only people to benefit from casting doubt on my …Go back to what @Falmiis said, he said himself he couldn't take any action on night 2 since his ability was locked in from night 1. That is exactly what I sa…(Oh, also happy birthday!)
I mean I think it's unlikely you're a naive tracker following the Carlos reveal, but I'm not sure there is a true discrepancy.
You tracked Falmiis on night 1 but the aeon slowed the action giving you a negative result for that night.
Oh, well I can only work with what the mod gives me.
Falmiis wandered around some after the town meeting, but I didn't see him be approached by anyone, was a significantly different message to the 'you can't watch Ssaliss, since he's not …
(c) Iron Realms Entertainment 2012.