Actually, if I had to suggest a structure for envoys, I'd rather just remove guild input on them - just appoint 5 from each org. We've had many situations in the past where envoys were appointed who weren't even the least bit qualified or interested…
Truth be told bias/pressure happens anyway and we have puppet envoys who only parrot someone else's opinion/ reports go on pastebin, so might as well open it up IMO.
IMO it was more rewarding because there were less "forced" versions of conflict/PK - people jumped in because they wanted to, not because a village/aetherflare/domoth/wildnodes/etc popped up. People are more likely to feel good about things if they …
FYI, it bugs me that not-more-than-a-few posters on this thread somehow just know that venting does not do you any good. Even after multiple others have posted on the contrary.