Portius · Likes big books, cannot lie
Reactions
Comments
-
Oh come on not again with the sniping.
-
Oh, sniped. Well, whatever. You guys really shouldn't have even believed me enough to make Silvanus do an explicit claim.
-
Well, this thread picked up fast than I expected. I'mma do some quoting.
(Quote) Don't think this really mirrors the Maeve claim. You know, since several people are claiming fairly minor characters. And I'm claiming a power that is… -
(Quote)
Emphasis mine once again.
-
(Quote) Not exactly true. On page 13, Lehki claims to start aligned with the fire nation, not as a third party. Shaddus did claim third party, though.
-
(Quote) Possibly also Aang, depending on the stage of the story we're at. Or Jeong Jeong. Possibly even the dragons, if they're in here. I don't think it's actually as much of a miller thing as it looks, just on the sheer number of good fireb…
-
(Quote)
But Silvanus has explicitly said that he doesn't have investigative know how. He then went on to kind of imply that he does, admittedly, but also to just claim survivor. Which seems contradictory. I generally take inconsi… -
(Quote)
So I had an image, but I couldn't get it to show up nicely in the preview. Pretend there's a nice picture of Angkor Wat here, with my asserting that it's a visual pun and you can figure out what it means.
It's getting… -
And I got sniped. Upon reading the post from Silvanus:
There's not actually an argument there. He's just asserting that I'm scum, and admitting that his basis for this is some fairly arbitrary grouping of players with questionable (or at … -
(Quote)
It's a name that keeps popping up because Silvanus has a bizarre desire to lynch me. Thus far, it doesn't seem like there are terribly many people who agree with him.
I mean, I can claim if I have to. I'd rather not, … -
(Quote) Not all third parties are survivors. Also, it's a separate win condition. They win by surviving until the end of the game, or by predicting enough lynches, or by being the only one left alive. Some of those can happen at the sa…
-
This is going to make me sound like an idiot. When faced with something that makes little to no sense, I tend to assume that I'm the one who is missing something. Right now, I'm staring at Silvanus' statement and having absolutely no idea how it cou…
-
Ok, worked out why I'm confused by Silvanus:
If you are targeted by a lie detector, does that return a result that says you're immune, or one that says whatever you said is true? I assumed it would just confirm your statements as true, bu… -
(Quote)
Is there some specific activity in particular you want from me? I assume you're not asking me to claim on day two.
I try not to say things unless I think I have something useful to add. So I pointed out why I think F… -
I win with Team Avatar.
-
...or not killing him and trying to work around a lie detector, which is at worst a day investigator that might have some people immune to it. Unless I'm being dumb and missing something?
Post separated because I had two windows ope… -
For that specific claim, I think Fal's actions were pretty reasonable. It'd be dumb without some sort of reliable night defense, but if he has that, it's pretty decent. Used as it is, it's functionally a day investigator.
Which is actuall… -
Guess who got to schedule two urgent vet visits within a couple hours of each other? This guy.
-
I think I'm willing to join this train. Falaeron was pretty obviously claiming a lie detector power from the start, so I'm pretty suspicious of excessive reluctance. The back pedaling seems pretty desperate, too.
Vote Othero
-
I have one big question here, as someone who hasn't seen Avatar in a long time:
Did Toph demonstrate an ability to detect lies during the show?
-
I win with Team Avatar.
-
(Quote) I will assume that she's female when I think of anything other than Lars Ulrich when I hear her last name.
-
@Isune told me to share.
If any of you were wondering on the people who narrated the Hallifax event post, I think this is all of them:
In… -
(Quote)
I can't comment on the reasons for this, but there's this and other occasional problems. Like, some places assume that vegetarians eat fish, and label accordingly. It's a pain. If you've ever wondered why vegetarians tend to mak… -
Just doing the traditional check-in so people know that I'm paying attention.
-
Same deal. Will sign up but step aside if others want in.
-
Also because it's a missed opportunity that I will never forgive myself for considering but not taking:
I briefly considered dropping Maeve claim after the Silvanus post, claiming that my role text was actually the quantum twin section at… -
Ok, because it's kind of funny and illustrates the dangers of not letting a scum group (because soulless functionally were by win condition, since we wanted to kill everyone but each other) know each other's identities, powers, number of people, or …
-
To this day, I have no idea how Ushaara didn't just get lynched for claiming a traitor. And in a game with a very finite number of claimable roles, the last couple people to claim should be heavily suspect by default just because it's so dangerous t…
(c) Iron Realms Entertainment 2012.