@Alary Can you give more info on your investigator power? Right now it seems like it is either a bit untrust worthy or you're not getting the full picture on p…
Ifeel like you don't get mafia. why does knowing my role help out the town right now? That is my biggest question when considering a role claim because there is not enough pressure for me to claim in an attempt to save myself. A role claim always he…
Because mafia isn't really about evidence, it's about your opinion. The game requires people to talk and give their opinion. Not speaking up is naturally suspicious and usually means you're staying quiet so you don't have to lie or accidently share …
So yeah, honestly after reading it I don't have much to add. They're both suspicious, Cyndarin's power is a bit tough to swallow but there is the chance that Eldanien is some sort of mafia investigator. The number of claims really only helped the ma…
I did not receive any nightmares or had anything happen to me. I'll have some more thoughts after work, I need to read back through Celina and Eldanien's argument before I get an opinion.
(Quote)
But the problem isn't roleplaying, the problem is if it is a good idea or not to take a shot in the dark with a kill. You've played enough of both to know a shot in the dark is a dangerous move.
Just checking in, nothing happened to me last night. I'm not sure about Tremula but I'd be willing to lynch if we don't find stronger info. Anyone who was jailed or blocked last night is obviously suspicious.
(Quote)
I'm just going to second this. And the idea that Vivet is pro-town and isn't playing to win is really nice but we can't assume that's true. Believing that someone is not playing the game to win is dangerous.
I'm totally down for an alternative and I'd like to make sure everyone chimes in on this before we lynch. New players, even if you're confused I know you have an opinion. Everyone's got one.
(Quote)
Not really. If she sticks with us and helps the town the mafia will kill her, a doctor is not going to waste their time protecting a survivor. She's safer helping the mafia. A survivor during lynch or lose is a powerful spot and…
Do you have a solid alternative then? Would you want to lynch Ieptix or is this not enough to actually lynch? If you don't want to go with Vivet that's cool and makes some sense. However, we need an alternative to go with if it's not going to be Viv…
Also being AFK at a nexus isn't a victim free crime. It sucks to show up at a nexus, see a large group to interact with and play with, and have it turn out that most of them are AFK. This really sucks if you're a new player showing up at your nexus …
Hey, sorry for not posting earlier. I'd been dealing with some health issues this weekend and had been keeping up on my phone but couldn't actually post. My phone is allergic to posting on the forums. I'm finally on a laptop and I'm thinking Vote…
(Quote)
I'm going to be honest, this has never been true. You need to actively punish, shun, and ostracize trolls. If someone's behavior is unacceptable and negatively effecting a community you can't just ignore them. I mean, you as an …