I only thought that Saobutt was Calcifer because of the -perfect- supporting fluff (hindsight: I took the heart thing too literally) and because, damn, I wanted to be right. I just floated a theory and openly admitted it was based on speculative int…
While I may have been wrong about Calcifer, I wasn't wrong about Saobutt being a Lover. And if I was scum, I probably would have tried to kill Sao last night (as a heavily suspected 2 for 1, with an arsonist), instead of going all conspiracy th…
Well, I agree, it could have been worse. The couple apparently had like.. no power (never would have guessed that). So we don't lose some great utility.
@saobutt To weed out the truth through your many posed hypotheticals, it seems obvious that you're part of a Lovers role (i.e., two lives connected) and your…
Not too sure what you mean, Arix. There was only a few minutes left in the day, and we had to make a quick decision with the new information. Sidd had already mentioned he wanted to vote for Tremula, but had to prioritize saving Shaddus. I just agre…
Well, sorry Trem. I feel a bit bad about how that turned out, because once I had time to properly process, I soon recognized Saobutt's cryptic last-ditch signals and regretted not having her lynched. Early in day one after the arsonist speculat…
Since Shaddus is safe and we're running out of time, I'm going to Vote Tremula . I have to agree with Sidd's logic, as I don't see why Tremula decided to out her involvement in the first place.
I'd guess there's also the small possibility that Silvanus was targeted by the arsonist, but I dunno, looks like we can't really draw any conclusions at this point.
Maybe it would be useful to speculate a bit about the arsonist's alignment, going under the assumption that it could be Calcifer. I haven't seen that movie, but I did a little google-fu and he d…
For the sake of conversation (and the mafia noobs like me), what are the options? Assuming nothing crazy happens, my understanding is: We take a shot with very little (no?) information, with greater likelihood that we hit town but a big(?) advantage…