It's been my master plan all along All hail Lady PEEPALINEMboagn said:Going by Thalkros's idea, we'd finally have a Beauty TA.
Nepenthe said:Idol: Eritheyl
Orael said:Ok, Here's what's happening
So when we consider our decisions on what to do to make it the most fair for both parties, it comes down to really two options - we either remove Parhelion as TA (and neither side gets one) or we raise Ixion (and both sides get one). We decided to not remove Parhelion and instead of raise Ixion. No bonus, no extra, just a TA for both sides.
I won't say that there isn't anything else we're willing to do, but I haven't really seen any solution that comes across to me as more fair -for everyone- presented here.
That's great news, I know you're relieved.Shulamit said:Chubby cat's lumps were benign.
I think that this is the part that is making so many in Glom/Celest/Halli angry and dejected. People feel like they put in the work and won. People feel like they earned it. It's very disheartening for the admin to actually come out and say, "No, we don't know that you earned it" and modify the outcome of ascension as a result. This is, in fact, what people are unhappy about.
It was a win, by the rules of ascension. Would people have preferred a lag-free win? Sure. But it's not great when the administration comes out and says, "Hey, you won by the rules but that's not enough for us to think you actually earned it."
Edit: Ixion's ascension feels pretty set in stone to me at this point from what the admin are saying, but I encourage admin to take into account the feelings I described above. It's possible to give Ixion and people who support him the benefits that would make them happier, while respecting the feelings of the players who won by the rules as they were laid out ahead of time, and who feel like that should be acknowledged.
I think the central confusion is with your language here. You only gave one side TA, the other side (feels) they earned their TA. Give vs earn. Gave one side TA, so give the other side TA as well. The earned-TA notwithstanding. Etc.Orael said:So your point is that we should make Glom/Celest/Halli happy by giving them two TA's and Mag/Gaudi/Seren are supposed to be happy with one TA?
Mboagn said:They already acknowledged that they knew it was going to ruffle feathers any which way. From their assessment, this was the best solution out of a basket of bad solutions.